NEWS

Suprathyroid Gland and the Improved Reflexes Adept Power

  • 78 Replies
  • 30024 Views

8-bit

  • *
  • Guest
« Reply #60 on: <09-07-14/2337:54> »
You do realize that there is a difference between the increase to Reaction Attribute that Wired Reflexes provide and the increase to Reaction Attribute that Attribute Boost [Reaction] provide, right?

Wired Reflexes increase Reaction Attribute which also increase (give a bonus to / also affects) Initiative [Attribute].
Attribute Boost [Reaction] increase Reaction Attribute but does not also increase Initiative [Attribute].


Wired Reflexes increase your [Physical] Initiative (both with the bonus to Initiative [Attribute] and with the bonus to Initiative Dice).
Attribute Boost [reaction] does not increase your [Physical] Initiative.

Not at my books right now, but reread the Attribute Boost description. It specifically states that Attribute only affects dice pools. I don't want to join in this argument, but your argument is, in the is case, just wrong.

@justkelly

Thanks for your explanation, that is how I personally view it as well. Thank you for your opinion.

If anything is messed up in terms of spelling, I blame autocorrect on the phone.

Namikaze

  • *
  • Freelancer Ltd
  • Prime Runner
  • **
  • Posts: 4068
  • I'm a Ma'fan of Shadowrun!
« Reply #61 on: <09-08-14/0041:11> »
The fact that Attribute Boost [Reaction] doesn't affect Initiative is explicitly a limitation that is defined with the power.  Therefore, it has no impact at all on this discussion.  It's just outright irrelevant.

At this point, Xenon, I've defined from the book, the different attributes, how they're derived, and the limitations of a number of effects.  You have not once provided evidence supporting your opinion that an increase to a stat that also impacts Initiative is the same as an increase to Initiative.
Feel free to keep any karma you earned illicitly, it's on us.

Quote from: Stephen Covey
Most people do not listen with the intent to understand; they listen with the intent to reply.

Xenon

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 6471
« Reply #62 on: <09-08-14/0304:30> »
Both improved reflexes and wired reflexes explicit state that they also affect initiative [attribute] and/or [physical] initiative (depending on your reading).

An increase to reaction also give a bonus to / affects initiative [attribute] and [physical] initiative. They are tied together. The only time you can increase reaction without affecting initiative attribute and physical initiative is if the enhancement explicit state that it does not affect initiative.

When you activate wired reflexes you get an increased reaction, initiative attribute, initiative dice, initiative score and physical initiative.

The increase to reaction might or might not stack with improved reflexes, but the increase to initiative attribute (and physical attribute) does not stack with improved reflexes.

You can have both improved reflexes 2 and wired reflexes 2 at the same time. It might or might not increase your reaction attribute up to the augmented maximum of 4, but you can't stack improved reflexes with increases to physical initiative (or initiative attribute, still not really clear which one of the two they mean here) so you can't stack them both to get an increased initiative attribute of 4 (or an increased physical initiative of 4 and 4d6).

It does seem as if increased reflexes spell might stack with wired reflexes (but not with improved reflexes or synaptic boosters).

Synaptic boosters doesn't even stack with drugs.

Adrenaline Boost stack with wired reflexes and increase reflexes... depending on if improved reflexes talk about initiative [attribute] or [physical] initiative it might or might not stack with this power as well.

Attribute boost reaction stack with improved reflexes (unlike WR it does not affect initiative attribute nor physical initiative), wired reflexes and increase reflexes. Doesn't stack with synaptic boosters.



P.160 talk about increasing initiative by activating an augmentation. Increasing initiative by 2 by activating an implant. I let you decide if they tall about initiative attribute or  physical initiative here,  but I like to point out that all augmentations that increase initiative attribute does so by increasing your reaction attribute.

Xenon

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 6471
« Reply #63 on: <09-08-14/0305:12> »
The whole point of getting weird reflexes is to increase your initiative (!)

Namikaze

  • *
  • Freelancer Ltd
  • Prime Runner
  • **
  • Posts: 4068
  • I'm a Ma'fan of Shadowrun!
« Reply #64 on: <09-08-14/0320:54> »
Both improved reflexes and wired reflexes explicit state that they also affect initiative [attribute] and/or [physical] initiative (depending on your reading).

Prove it.  Wired reflexes and improved reflexes explicitly state that they improve the Reaction and Initiative Dice of the recipient.  Show me where it says that it improves Initiative directly, and I'll eat my shoes.  The only line in here about improving Initiative is the part about how the bonus to Reaction also affects Initiative.

Quote from: Core Book, page 310
This power increases the speed at which you react, just like wired reflexes. For each level, you receive +1 to Reaction (this also affects Initiative) and +1D6 Initiative Die (to a maximum of 5D6). The maximum rating of Improved Reflexes is 3, and the increase cannot be combined with other technological or magical increases to Initiative.

Quote from: Core Book, page 455
Wired reflexes: This highly invasive, painful, life-changing operation adds a multitude of neural boosters and adrenaline stimulators in strategic locations throughout your body work to catapult you into a whole new world where everything around you seems to move in slow motion. The system includes both manual and wireless triggers to turn the wired reflexes on and off; activating or deactivating the trigger manually requires a Complex Action, doing so wirelessly is a Simple Action.
When activated, each rating point of wired reflexes gives you +1 Reaction (and accompanying bonus to Initiative) and +1D6 Initiative Die. Wired reflexes are incompatible with augmentations that affect Reaction or Initiative.
Wireless: The system is compatible with wireless reaction enhancers, and the total Reaction bonus from both systems can be above +4 if both systems have wireless active.

They are tied together.

Yes and no.  Reaction is a part of Initiative, because Initiative is derived from Reaction.  But if you increase Initiative, it doesn't necessarily result in an increase to Reaction (or Intuition for that matter).

When you activate wired reflexes you get an increased reaction, initiative attribute, initiative dice, initiative score and physical initiative.

Not true.  When you activate Wired Reflexes, you get a bonus to Reaction and Initiative Dice.  The bonus to reaction also affects you derived Initiative.  Since you seem to have difficulty understanding how derivation works, let me give you a definition and example:

de·rive verb \di-ˈrīv, dē-\
: to take or get (something) from (something else)

: to have something as a source : to come from something

This means that if I have a bushel of apples, and I make a bunch of apple pies with those apples, I have derived an apple pie from the apples.  The apple pie is not the apples, and the apples are not the apple pie.  But they are intrinsically related to each other.



The increase to reaction might or might not stack with improved reflexes, but the increase to initiative attribute (and physical attribute) does not stack with improved reflexes.

You can have both improved reflexes 2 and wired reflexes 2 at the same time. It might or might not increase your reaction attribute up to the augmented maximum of 4, but you can't stack improved reflexes with increases to physical initiative (or initiative attribute, still not really clear which one of the two they mean here) so you can't stack them both to get an increased initiative attribute of 4 (or an increased physical initiative of 4 and 4d6).

Might or might not?  I thought you were definitive in your position here.

It does seem as if increased reflexes spell might stack with wired reflexes (but not with improved reflexes or synaptic boosters).

Synaptic boosters doesn't even stack with drugs.

Adrenaline Boost stack with wired reflexes and increase reflexes... depending on if improved reflexes talk about initiative [attribute] or [physical] initiative it might or might not stack with this power as well.

Attribute boost reaction stack with improved reflexes (unlike WR it does not affect initiative attribute nor physical initiative), wired reflexes and increase reflexes. Doesn't stack with synaptic boosters.

None of these things are in question here.  The topic is about the suprathyroid gland and improved reflexes.  It feels like you're trying to further derail this topic in an effort to not admit you're wrong.  Additionally, you're applying the stacking bonus to Reaction in some examples, and stating that a bonus to Reaction can't stack in other examples.

P.160 talk about increasing initiative by activating an augmentation. Increasing initiative by 2 by activating an implant. I let you decide if they tall about initiative attribute or  physical initiative here,  but I like to point out that all augmentations that increase initiative attribute does so by increasing your reaction attribute.

Who cares if all augmentations that increase Initiative do so via the Reaction attribute?

The whole point of getting weird reflexes is to increase your initiative (!)

I don't see why you felt the need to make another post just to say this.  This isn't in question, Xenon.

I've cited the book multiple times, I've given you hard facts to back up my opinion, others have chimed in to agree with my interpretation.  If you won't let it go, I will.  This is just getting silly at this point, because I am repeating myself over and over again, but you keep changing your opinion in order to keep an argument going.  Good day, Xenon.
Feel free to keep any karma you earned illicitly, it's on us.

Quote from: Stephen Covey
Most people do not listen with the intent to understand; they listen with the intent to reply.

Xenon

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 6471
« Reply #65 on: <09-08-14/0551:24> »
Prove that an increase to reaction "also affects" / give "accompanying bonus to" / "accompanying adjustment to" initiative attribute and physical limit?

First of all. That is a list of phrases that improved reaction, wired reflexes and synaptic boosters use in the book. They increase reaction and they "also affects" / give "accompanying bonus to" / "accompanying adjustment to" initiative attribute and physical limit. p. 310, 455 and 461.
 
Second. When you alter reaction you will also alter your initiative attribute as well (as your physical initiative and physical limit). If your reaction decreases then so will your initiative attribute (and physical initiative and physical limit). If your reaction increase so will your initiative attribute (and physical initiative and physical limit). In the case of wired reflexes and improved reflexes it even remind the reader to adjust the initiative (but since you always do it by default they didn't have to be extra clear about it). For attribute boost they don't want your increase to reaction to also affect your initiative attribute and physical initiative, but in this case they have to state so. And they did.

Third. Let us use basic math. A = B + C where both B and C are known. Increase B without altering C gives that A must increase with the same amount as B.

Or if you rather talk about pie; If you increase the amount of apples then you will also increase the amount of apple pie. Increase Reflexes give you a bigger pie but is not compatible to other increases to the pie (such as adding more apples, adding more doe or even adding more apple pie directly).

Forth. Initiative might mean either [physical] initiative or initiative [attribute]. You are assuming that Improved Reflexes is incompatible with increase to Initiative Attribute. Your assumption might or might not be correct. For all we know Improved Reflexes might be incompatible with increase to Physical Initiative....

Fifth. If the book would have said that Wired Reflexes "...increase Reaction Attribute (and accompanying bonus to Initiative), +1D6 Initiative Attribute and also increase Initiative Attribute directly" then you would double dip and Initiative Attribute would be increased twice.



"Who cares if all augmentations that increase Initiative do so via the Reaction attribute?"

That is the whole point.

Improved reflexes increase initiative via the Reaction attribute and it is incompatible with other increases to Initiative (that might come from increases to Reaction Attribute, but there are other ways to increase Initiative besides increasing Reaction.... directly increasing initiative attribute,  for example).


Improved Reflexes "cannot be combined with other ... increases to Initiative". You don't read this as Improved Reflexes is also increasing Initiative in its own??


If you get improved reflexes or turn on your wired reflexes  then your initiative will increase. It is why you get them to begin with. I don't even understand how this can be under debate... You are seriously arguing that wired reflexes does not increase initiative and that it stack with improved reflexes. That you would get +4 initiative attribute and +4D6 initiative dice if you get improved reflexes 2 and wired reflexes 2 at the same time; despite the fact improved reflexes is clearly incompatible with other increases to initiative. other increases. Other. (Hint: they typed other because improved reflexes increase initiative on its own).

(And to make matters worse, for all we know the author might be taking about Physical Initiative here,  not Initiative Attribute).
« Last Edit: <09-08-14/0927:01> by Xenon »

ZeConster

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 2557
« Reply #66 on: <09-08-14/0659:29> »
Honestly, I feel they have complicated things so much this is something that needs intent clarification.

prismite

  • *
  • Omae
  • ***
  • Posts: 268
« Reply #67 on: <09-08-14/0932:52> »
Oh lord ... I must be out of my mind. Why? Because for all of the times I disagree with Xenon, I totally see his point and whats worse ... I agree.

While its true that the book is (and generally tends to be) somewhat ambiguous, I think I'd agree that anything that boosts the Initiate score would be a boost to Initiative. So, an item/ability that gives me 3 Reaction dice is thereby boosting my Initiative by 3.

Yes, I get that Initiative is a derived attribute and that one can (and several HAVE) argued that semantics say that Initiative is not all-encompassing of Reaction/Intuition.

To me this is akin to saying your Car is not street legal if it has 1,000 horsepower, then trying to explain to the officer that the car doesnt have 1,000 horsepower ... the "engine" does.

*shrug*
Want to join a skype game on R20 on Sundays? PM me!

The Wyrm Ouroboros

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 4471
  • I Have Taken All Shadowrun To Be My Province
« Reply #68 on: <09-08-14/1018:20> »
Xenon, you're way off-base in regards to Reaction and Intuition; increasing either one results in an increase to your Initiative, yes, but is not in and of a direct increase to Initiative, which is the entire frelling point.

Namikaze, having discovered that you somehow feel that there is a seperation between 'an increase to Initiative' and 'an increase to Initiative' and 'increases Initiative' when one adds points to your 'Initiative secondary attribute', the second adds to your Initiative dice, and the third adds to your 'Initiative score', I have to admit that while you may somehow have a technical argument in your favor, you're being as goddamn pedantic about the differences between those - when they get used almost interchangeably in the book - as Xenon is in regards to increases in Reaction/Intuition being Initiative boosts.

So frankly, at this point I'd say you're both wrong.

An increase to Initiative is an increase to the score, the figured attribute, and/or initiative dice.  These are just that: increases to Initiative.  If something is incompatable with other increases to initiative, it doesn't matter which one of the three it is, or you think it is; that's immaterial, because it is incompatable.  An increase to Reaction is not an increase to Initiative; an increase to Intuition is not an increase to Initiative.  Both of those may - will - affect Initiative by dint of increasing the base attribute from which Initiative is derived, but they aren't initiative increases.

Geez.
Pananagutan & End/Line

Old As McBean, Twice As Mean
"Oh, gee - it's Go-Frag-Yourself-O'Clock."
New Wyrm!! Now with Twice the Bastard!!

Laés is ... I forget. -PiXeL01
Play the game. Don't try to win it.

8-bit

  • *
  • Guest
« Reply #69 on: <09-08-14/1200:59> »
which is the entire frelling point.

Do I sense a Farscape reference?

prismite

  • *
  • Omae
  • ***
  • Posts: 268
« Reply #70 on: <09-08-14/1238:15> »
I see your point, TWO, I do ... but I still see it the other way.

Looks like this is going to be one of those things that gets left up for each individual table to decide on how they want to rule it.

That is, unless/until we get an official declaration from someone in-the-know.
Want to join a skype game on R20 on Sundays? PM me!

Xenon

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 6471
« Reply #71 on: <09-08-14/1246:11> »
If you agree that activating wired reflexes give you higher initiative then it will not stack with improved reflexes. At least not for the purpose of adjusting initiative.


If you disagree that activating wired reflexes give you higher initiative then you are free to stack it with improved reflexes.


I can't really explain it more simple than that.

Xenon

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 6471
« Reply #72 on: <09-08-14/1413:36> »
An increase to Initiative is an increase to....
Yes, it is not unlikely that when they type Initiative in this case they mean [Physical] Initiative (p. 159)
- and not at all Initiative [Attribute] (p. 52)

...something I pointed out several times by now. Here is one recent example:
Initiative might mean either [physical] initiative or initiative [attribute]. You are assuming that Improved Reflexes is incompatible with increase to Initiative Attribute. Your assumption might or might not be correct. For all we know Improved Reflexes might be incompatible with increase to Physical Initiative.
(this is a topic I even had a fun, but rather lively, debate on with ZeConster some months ago where I defended the idea that they meant [Physical] Initiative while he argued for the idea that they meant Initiative [Attribute]... IIRC so he could stack Adrenaline Boost and Improved Reflexes).

ZeConster

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 2557
« Reply #73 on: <09-08-14/1714:31> »
(this is a topic I even had a fun, but rather lively, debate on with ZeConster some months ago where I defended the idea that they meant [Physical] Initiative while he argued for the idea that they meant Initiative [Attribute]... IIRC so he could stack Adrenaline Boost and Improved Reflexes).
You seem to have mistaken me having an opinion about something with me having a stake in something. I've never used the Adrenaline Boost power.

Xenon

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 6471
« Reply #74 on: <09-09-14/0702:53> »
You seem to have mistaken...
Ohh. In that case I'm sorry.