Human 1
Elf 3
Ork 5
Dwarf 5
Troll 8
To be fair, we also have to count negatives here:
- Human - 1 point of Edge
- Elf - 1 point of Agility, 2 points of Charisma, Low-Light Vision
- Dwarf - 2 Points Body, 2 Points Strength, 1 Point Willpower, Thermographic Vision, +2 to Pathogen/Toxin resistance, -1 Max Reaction, +20% Lifestyle
- Ork - 3 Points Body, 2 Points Strength, Low-Light Vision, -1 Logic Maximum, - 1 Charisma Maximum
- Troll - 4 Points Body, 4 Points Strength, Thermographic Vision, +1 Reach, +1 dermal armor, -1 Agility Maximum, -1 Logic Maximum, -1 Intuition Maximum, -2 Charisma Maximum, +100% lifestlye
So, let's assign some values to the things that aren't directly attributes. I'm going to go with a baseline of everything being equivalent to 1/2 attribute point, with +20% Lifestyle being 1/2 attribute point. This brings us to:
- Human - 1
- Elf - 3.5
- Dwarf - 5
- Ork - 4.5
- Troll - 5.5
This puts all metatypes more or less on even footing with a very mild difference. But, hey, we all know that Body and Strength are worth less than other attributes. Let's count positive points in them as being 1/2 attribute points.
- Human - 1
- Elf - 3.5
- Dwarf - 3.5
- Ork - 2
- Troll - 0.5
This is a very rough estimate, but I think it fits how people actually feel the metatypes work out. Troll is actually about even with Human. Ork is a bit better. Elf and Dwarf are pretty much the best (albeit at slightly different things).