So, for the lightning ball he had counterspelling as well (which may have been a miss-use of it, but didn't help all that much either way), as well as being un-injured, un-electrocuted and standing up (the "free action to stand up" was for story purposes not crunch). His total die pool for dodging your fist is 8. He'd get 4 more dice for Edge That's 12 dice, getting 8 hits on 12 dice even with explodes is statistically almost impossible. For funsies here you go:
Dodgy Dodge plus Edge:
12d6h5 5 So, 3 net hits, he's got to soak 14P as DV exceeds armor
Soaking 14P:
11d6t5 1 lets use that last point of edge to re-roll misses
re-rolling misses:
10d6t5 2So, he's eating 11P, he's got a body of 2 giving him 2 boxes of overflow. Being at 6P to start, he could only survive five more P before expiring... he took 11. Shmoooshed face.
FWIW, he's wearing a long coat armor 9 (now slightly singed so armor

, so I technically gave hime 2 extra dice on soaking anyway. Though he rolls so statistically poorly (which they've been doing the whole encounter) that I could have given him 4 extra dice and re-rolled the misses and he *still* would have died.
Some extra insight here: when I designed the encounter (6 months ago), I didn't take how effective ball-lightning would be into account and had the idea that the 10 mooks would keep Knucks and Expo at least a *little* occupied for at least 1 CT if not two. Simply in the number of times they each had to punch things

. The mage would have made things interesting, and he has(d) Masking which is why Uff's assensing trips didn't pick him up. The dude is actually a pretty badass mage, but not much for physical defense.
Also, you guys came up with a good plan and executed well. I don't think its fair for me to completely change the encounter based on your successes. So, advantage players. It just went a little easier than expected, however you guys miss out on some extra stuff because of an overly large amount of death

I also learned a lot about scene building, or lack there of. You guys handled the Chulos really well also. I probably under-estimated the capabilities of the various characters and made things a bit too simple. But, done is done. The title of the story was more for me than it was for what was happening in the story, especially as you guys didn't really get much in the way of "fire"... well except for a little internal microwaving of Knucks, but he probably does almost as much damage with his drug use
