I had assumed the "I am GOD!" was either the poster summarizing his GM's actual response and/or had been offered "tounge in cheek" by the GM. I agree whole heartedly that the only time the GM should be shouting
Kneel before Zod! is during a particularly memorable sesion of
Mutants & Masterminds. Clearly, I wasn't at the table and don't know exactly what happened.
However, he did say that the
entire group is new to the system, he also said (and this, I beleive, is key) they all had
fun. Sure, the GM made a bad call... I get that. I firmly beleive his players ought to bring it up with him before the next session and he should listen to their feedback. Several years ago, I wrote my
Batgirl's Gamemastering Tips for the
M&M message board. I still stand by my ideas in that post, although I recognize the higher degree of "crunch" in
SR4 makes it a little less applicable... but all GM's will make mistakes, that's life.
I would hate to see new players get turned off by a bad ruling from a GM, and I'd hate to see a new GM get turned off because of a bad reaction from his players. Be polite, point out the error, and have another go next weekend.
