I'm curious what reactions'll be to this one. It's probably the most "this isn't for everyone" book I've seen in a long time -- just the nature of this beast, I guess -- but I think the folks who dig it are gonna really dig it.
I need to find some time to read it properly, just been browsing through it in the afternoon (yes it's evening where I live) and I'm liking it so far. It feels like a refreshing take on the Shadowrun tropes, and after quite a few techno-centric metaplots I appreciate a visit to the metaplanes for a change, with all their weirdness and magical intrigues. In spirit, Court of Shadows reminds me a lot of Harlequin's Back, with a setting that feels less "random" and more connected to the "regular" Sixth World.
A few notes:
I appreciate that while not directly making links to Earthdawn it's not actively contradicting it either. The few mentions of the "Age of Legend" brought a smile to my face.
On a similar note: when I try this setting with my players, I'll totally have them meet some creepy elves with bloody thorns protruding from their bodies.
I think some things are a bit confusing. Stuff the writer(s) probably felt was obvious but really isn't.
For instance Brane Deigh is described as a changeling, which I guess refers to the folklore that fae replace (meta)human babies with fae babies. But then the word changeling is also used for doppelgangers, which seem to be an entirely different concept.
Another example: "Working with an Adept" is listed as one of the ways to find the way to the Seelie Court, but what an Adept is or why they have their entries to the Seelie Court doesn't seem to be explained anywhere (not by searching Adept in the pdf in any case). Is it meant to be the same thing as the regular "physical/mystical adept" archetype?
Last but not least, the way the Seelie Court is retroactively worked into the history of the world sometimes feels forced and unnatural, like
the War of Sorrows being mentioned as the source of the racism/bigotry against magical/metahuman races, or people searching for the Court after the Awakening
in the hope to "cure" their awakened/goblinized children. If the latter was said to be specific to Ireland I would say why not, but the text makes it feel like it was a worldwide craze, which feels very artificial.
That's just the things I've noticed so far.
Oh, and I love that cover art. Any hope for a wallpaper version?